Discuss Durkheim's distinction between the sacred and the profane. Critically examine it.
Tanuj Pathak, AIR 72, 2023
Sacred and Profane →
Durkheim in his book ' Elementary forms of religious life ' 1912 has described his idea of Sacred & Profane. He had studied ARUNTA tribe of Australia.
- Profane → Realm of Routine experience; Mundane activities - Sacred → Higher status than Profane; generate feeling of awe, worship, respect.
According to Durkheim, Totemic entity in Arunta was considered as Sacred. Anything marked by Totemic symbol was considered sacred. Sacred objects were kept apart and forbidden. Profane could not see or touch sacred. whenever people were near their totemic symbol (sacred) they felt Effervescence. Effervescence is a feeling of collective enthusiasm that binds the people together.
Durkheim said that Totem in itself was not capable to generate such strong feeling of awe, worship, etc. It was the society/group feeling itself which provides the feeling that sustains religion. Thus, Worship of totem meant worship of society. People give society a divinity form as it stand apart from the members and exert influences over them.
CRITICISM →
1. GOODY → says that translated word for Sacred / Profane is not found in various societies. Thus this idea is Not universal as claimed by Durkheim. 2. Evans Pritchard → in his study of Azande says, Ancestor names are used as a place of worship sanctimic (sacred), but other time it is used to rest their spears (profane).
Sacred & Profane since Durkheim →
1. Mary Douglas → in his book " Purity and Danger " studied the concept of purity and pollution. She draws parallel to Durkheims study of sacred and profane as he described religion as the study of absolute two opposed categories (Sacred vs profane) 2. V. Loyd Warner studied the memorial rites of modern tribes. He suggest that it represent some form of collective conciousness in his as proposed by Emile durkheim study of Sacred and profane.