Topper Copies

Analyse the substantivist and formalist view in economic anthropology.

Tanuj Pathak, AIR 72, 2023

This debate is about how to study the economic transactions in simple primitive societies. Debate was introduced by Karl Polanyi in his book "Great Transformation" 1944. He gave the concept of Substantivism i.e. Modern economics has nothing to do with Tribal economy as it is embedded in their Social Matrix. But formalist countered this view.

FORMALIST view →

Various scholar such as Schneider, Herskovits etc. believed that modern economic laws will be applied in studying simple economies because —

1. Principle of utility maximization is valid in Simple societies too. Everyone lives in the condition of Scarcity and unlimited wants. So are the people of simple societies. 2. Everyone takes the economic decision rationally. They will analyse all the given information and then take the best decision which will suit their personal interest.

CRITICISM -> Prattis calls their point as tautological. For instance, if some one is helping out of love or respect, Formalist will say, he is placing value on helping. But its not true.

- Kula Ring -> Example of Non-economic transaction. (by Malinowski)

SUBSTANTIVIST view →

- Karl Polanyi believe that Social relations of tribals must be included while studying their economy. - According to Sahlins -> Tribals do not maximise but rather they optimise. - According to Mark Granovetter -> The economic decisions of tribals is embedded in their social matrix. That is their decisions are based on Social ties relations like Kinship. - Eg -> POTLATCH in Kwakiutl. Dr. Franz Boas in "Kwakiutl Text' 1895' shows chiefs involve in Destruction of wealth to show closeness to their kins.

CRITICISM ->

- No society today can be called a totally pre-industrial society - Conditions of scarcity can happen anytime - anywhere.

Thus, today when Globalization and Modernization has penetrated simple societies, Anthropologist must use BOTH ways to studying Simple societies HOLISTICALLY.