Topper Copies

Reciprocity as a exchange system.

Tanuj Pathak, AIR 72, 2023

Reciprocity as a exchange system

Karl Polanyi in Great transformation (1944) gave 3 exchanges in simple society -> Reciprocity -> Redistribution -> Market exchange

Reciprocity is exchange of goods and services without the use of money.

SAHLINS gave 3 types -> Generalised -> Balanced -> Negative

(i) Generalised Reciprocity

Exchange of Goods & Services with NO expectation of return. Prevalent in hunting - gathering society

Eg. -> Korna Marshall studied food sharing in !KUNG

The hunter who killed the game share the meat with his two Co-hunters. They the share meat with their kins viz - parents, wives parents, wives, children, etc. This the form of Generalised reciprocity where there is only one way Transfer.

(ii) Balanced reciprocity

Exchange of goods and services either immediately or in a short period of time. That is, it is expected that the other person will return the favour with goods or service.

Eg: KULA Ring by Malinowski ("Argonauts of western Pacific 1922")

Involve exchange of non - economic items

Eg#2 Bantu ⟷ !Kung (Tobacco ⟷ Animal hide)

(iii) Negative reciprocity

In this exchange of goods and services, both parties try to benefit from the exchange, on the expense of another.

Eg In NAVAJO tribe of America, deceit is allowed while trading with foreigners.

Similarly, BARTER is also a form of Negative reciprocity.

Today, economic transactions are moving towards cash economy.