Topper Copies

Copying is safe; innovation demands courage.

Aakash Om Trivedi, AIR 73, 2025

It was time of 2000s. world was witnessing technology boom through rise of Google, spread of Internet. This boom revived only idea of Artificial Intelligence, a model that can perform tasks that normally human can do, among computer scientist. The standard approach involved creating of mathematical model, probability to predict outcome. This was seen as safe bet as it has made progress in some scenario like recommendation system. But, there was young Canadian PhD holder, who thought this won't work in complex system. He look beyond his peer and innovated Artifical Neural Network. Intial model were not good due to lalk of data, low computing facilities. But, courageous he was he went to researching. And Fast forward 2020s, rise of ChatGPT is based on his work. He got Noble-prize in 2024 for neural network resembling Brain. He is non-other that "Godfather of AI": Geoffery Hinton.

This anecdote highlight that though copying is seen as safe, through courage we can innovate new ideas. Lets first understand meaning of copying and innovation. Copying involves emulating pervious work often the work that have succeded. For instance, building model that succeded in USA of skyscapers, emulated across globe. whereas, innovation entails to find newer approach toward same scenario. This means in previous scenario, one need new model of urban building, beyond skyscapers. For instance, Chandigarh Le-corbuier provided new urban model for balancing aesthetics and urban needs.

Copying is safe; innovation demand courge

Copying is seen as safe for reasons such as it is easy to emulate as one is already aware of all steps and processes involved. For instance, Chinese Alibaba was seen as copy of American Amazon e-commerce application. Alibaba founder Jack Ma had seen amazon rise, understood its process through analysis and emulated it in Chinese market. He beforehand was aware of challenges of inventory, order return and delivery cost and also knew solution as Amazon had already figured out all of this. He just had to implement it.

Similarly, copying is seen as less risky bet as one know it has already succeded. This make it safe bet to follow with maximum scope of progress historically we saw success of Britain Industrial revolution was seen by European countries like Germany who saw it as successful model for progress resulting in them following footsteps of Britain through copying same model.

Further, copying doesn't require one to think and put additional effort in creating new making it less risky. This is seen in corporate world, where fashion companies often copy traditional design, often unique, intricate and sell with brand. Recent kolapuri-Chappal and Prada case reflect this.

having seen why copying is safe bet, let explore reason for innovation requiring courage.

Innovation requires courage to think out of box beyond present existing theories that are well-established. It require one to take "ROAD NOT TAKEN BY MANY" in Robert Forst words. In scientific world, newtonian mechanics was well-established. And it was seen major research were built on that. But, Einstein through his courage to think out of box create thought experiment of man travelling in life with speed of light. This lead to new innovation in mechanics through "Theory of relativity".

Further, innovation requires one to have guts to take risk, follow against present tides. It involves avoiding copying and pursuing newer approach. For instance, with Yahoo dominance in search, Sergey Brin found new innovation search algorithm "Pagerank" whereas all other Yahoo competitor were using same search algorithm. This innovation through courage to try new created "Google" as new dominant force in search.

In addition to this, courage to question status quo is vital for new ideas to emerge. In Bureaucracy, where weberian Iron age prevent innovation, young IAS Shubham Gupta saw malnutrition in tribal girl children. He question this status quo that despite mid-day-meal why such gaps. This lead him to use AI machine for targated intervention of nutrition deficiency in Nandurbar.

Moreover, courage to fail is also required in innovator as focus success come to repetitive iteration. for example, Elon musk SpaceX tried a bold innovation of Reusable rocket, not even tried by giant like NASA. This idea failed multiple times, rocket exploded in sky. But, courage to fail and standup lead to spacex making first large-scale -reusable rockets.

Similarly, courage to find new Ideas, shunning old ones and investing time in those idea crucial for new discovery. For example, Deepseek Founder focus on bettering algorithms rather than copying ChatGPT model and invested resources, time leading to new energy efficient innovative model.

Additionaly, courage to move beyond one comfort zone of just copying our nearby is crucial for progess. In Baramati, agriculture association persuade people to explor precision agriculture for sugarcane. Farmer move beyond their comfort zone, leading to more yields, export-opportunities and more income for them.

Other side of Coin

Now, we will see scenario where why copying is also not safe. for instance, blind imitation can't work if not adjusted to local condition. This is evident if Delhi Builder emulate New York skyscraper they can suffer lot of damage as Delhi lies in seismic Zone IV thus more vulnerable to earthquakes. This requires builder to move beyond blind copying as in such case copying become dangerous.

Also, there are times when though copying is safe but it still requires courage to implement it. What is needed is balance of copying and innovation in such scenario. For instance, our Constitution has borrowed principles of Federalism from USA; parliament from UK but we added innovation of Assymetric Federalism and Reservation in parliament for making it our in Indian Context.

having seen need to innovation and courage for progess, we will examine the challenge and way to overcome them.

first challenge to innovation is loss aversion mindset. It requires changing our outlook to embracing culture where failure is rewarded. This will provide people with courage to innovate. This requires supporting people that fail by seeing failures as experience not fatal wounds. The learning from Silicon valley culture where failed Startup Founder is prefer over new-one as he has understand and wisdom can be embraced in India.

Secondly, education that focus less on critical thinking that promote less creativity impedes innovation. It requires education to focus on experimentation opening your mind. The lesson from NITI Aayog Atal Tinkering labs where focus on innovation need to be promoted.

lastly, courage and innovation required "Can-do attitude" and persistence that require Emotional Intelligence. This must be added to curriculum, for instance, "Delhi Happiness Curriculum" focus on how to embrace failures.

The lesson from Gefforey Hinton highlight it is courage that sow seed of innovation and thus progress. To use words of Martin luther king "I have a dream that every Indian with his mind free of fear embrace innovation, not playing safe". This is central for becoming knowledge Economy in future and create more indigenous "Geffrey Hinton"