He who opens a school door, closes a prison.
Aakash Om Trivedi, AIR 73, 2025
In a coastal serene town of kerala, Sea witnessed story of two friends. They both came from poor background and shared same love for fishes. However, the difference between them was in their approach toward education. One was exteremely dedicated toward education, regularly went to school, studied day and night. In contrast other boy felt education is waste of his time he bunked classes and later drop out from school itself.
Fast forward to around 50 years, first boy is leading defence program also known across India as "missile man of India", our hero APJ kalam. Whereas, other boy who neglected education is in news as he is being caught for involvement in drug smuggling.
This incident, highlight the difference school door create in one destiny and how it closes a prison door and open us to new possibility. In this essay, we will explore the reason on how opening school is similar to closing prison. Then we will understand alongside how without school door how prison possibility enhances. Then we will go in scenario where with school access, still prison door is also present, and without school also one can avoid prison. And lastly we will understand Indian context and challenges and reforms required.
The reasons for one who opens a school door, also closes a prison door are firstly school provides us access to education. This education improves our skill, and employability. This opens new avenues for us in world for income generation. Whereas, without education access we are left with no skill. This result in limited options for income generation for survival. This pushes individuals toward unethical actions that enhances their chances of landing in prison. for instance, access to quality education technical skill due to his Harvard Background, Mark Zukerberg was able to invent facebook. In contrast, we witness drug peddling in Taliban by majority youth as that is their only way of survival. Such actions make them vulnerable to prison.
Secondly, Education provides you with ability to think for yourself. This promote introspection of our actions. This deter individual for performing action that are unethical and illegal that can land them in prison. This was evident when kerala police in Operation Pigeon, focus on radicalised youth by ISIS by using education as tool. Rather than direct punitive action, they focus on reformative. They went to their home, persuaded them and parent to send them to school and college. They supported them financially also. This resulted in substainal desradicalisation as youth through education started examining his choices leaving wrong action behind as him.
Further, education through school opens chances of social mobility among people. In contrast, lack of education doesn't provide us access to such ladder of social progress. This result in people of poor, criminal and vulnerable background with no education vulnerable to peer influence in locality. This is evident by US Department of Justice report, that highlight that people from Black background, and living in streets infamous for gun violence get more involved in gun violence. This was seen as black people has less education access compare to white and more vulnerable to their enviroment.
In addition to this, education plays crucial role in evolution of person. It is seen Education makes person transition from human being to being humane. It involves overcoming animalist instinct, understanding of values. For instance, the heinous crime of Nirbhaya case involved people lacking proper education and hadn't open school door for themselves. with education we understand what is our right to do, what is right thing to do.
For example, Lok Niti Survey highlight Educated politican use less hate speech in their rally compare to uneducated one. Education makes one utilise our rights in ethical manner. whereas lack of education led to abuse of one rights leading to prison scenario.
Further, without access to school door, youth often lack anything to do. This create scenario of "empty mind, devil workshop" as they use their free time for unethical activity. This is seen in Somalia where due to lack of school, youth from age of 10, get involved in piracy. Such action make them vulnerable to get caught and spend rest of life in prison.
Similarly, without access to education, one lack awareness of legal provision and one rights. Thus, there are scenario where people are in unjust manner caught in prison but due to lack of awareness rights spend life despite being innocent. This was highlighted by President Droupadi Murmu who highlight that undertrail in prison spend years despite being innocent as they lack education and thus, awarenes of rights, legal aid and process. She highlighted plight of Dongaria kondh tribal youth who spend prime of youth in prison despite innonce due to low education.
Lastly, if one person open door of school, one is likely to push the whole community toward light away for crime, The charismatic influence of person inspire other toward education closing their door toward prison also. This is reflect in Malala Yousfaiz journey who use "education as tool to change her radicalised community". Her courageous defiant despite attack by terrorist for education has inspired Pakistani girl to pursue education, Pakistani boys to move away from terrorism.
Having seen the reason of school closing door to prison, we will now see scenario where despite school door, one see prison afterward.
Firstly, when education is focus only on knowledge and lack empasis on values then it create clever devil as highlighted by C.S Lewis. Such person, use their knowledge for personal benefit, finding legal loopholes and doing illegal act. This pushes them to prison. for instance, narshad mehta, well educated stock broker, succembed to greed and manipulated stock market in 1992 leading to him spending time in prison.
Similarly, if your education is use for criminal activites then you are inviting prison to your house. for instance, in Jantara, tech-savvy youth, use technology for scamming people using education for illegal activites and subsequently they were punished.
On other hand, we have individuals who despite lacking school door, also closed prison. This is when they focus on skill such as creativity, art and through discipline master it. In this manner they despite missing school door, create other door for themselves through hard work, closing prison through this. For example, Eminem despite less educational background, focus on rap and persisted to become one of greatest rapper of all time.
Apart from this, one can get education without going to school through our surronding parent. The socialisation teaches us values that closes door of prison. for instance, Jadav Payeng despite lacking environmental education and proper schooling, influence by love of nature started planting tree in Majuli Island. Eventually, he became Forest man. In his case, he didn't just close prison door for him despite less education but open door of goodness through his values.
having seen this, we realise education and school door is crucial and they must be complemented by values and character. In such scenario, we permanatly closed prison door, and beyond that help humanity
Now, we will explore challenges in Indian education context. Despite Right to Education as fundamental right Art 21A, we are seeing school door still not accessible to all. This is due to lack of last mile connectivity of school, caste discrimination present denying opportunities. Alongside this, even education focus on rote-learning rather than critical thinking, less empasis on value based education is evident. Also, we are seeing rise in learning poverty as ASER report highlight low learning outcome as only 55% class 5 student read class 2 book.
All this challenges need to be reformed to truly open the school door. This is focused in NEP, 2020 reforms that put empasis on skill education, hand-on learning and value-based-education. It also focuses on Teacher-training through NISHTHA to improve pedagogy so student enjoy education. Alongside, this goal of universal foundational literacy is strengthing access to basic education at all through NIPUN.
As India is at crossroad, it is imperative to fulfil vision of greatest man of our generation "Mahatma Gandhi" that every child get education of hand, heart and head". Focusing on quality education for all will create more KALAM, achieve goal of preamble. As Martin luther king Jr highlight "INTELLIGENCE PLUS CHARACTER IS GOAL OF TRUE EDUCATION". This vision of school will guide us toward Vision of viksit Bharat @2047