Topper Copies

Ethnocentrism vis-à-vis cultural relativism

Tanuj Pathak, AIR 72, 2023

Culture relativism as a concept is given by Dr. franz boas. He says that different culture have evolved as per their own cultural circumstances. They have their own integrated way of life. Thus, the values of one culture must not be use to judge the values of another.

According to William G Summer → Ethnocentricism is that view of thing in which a person places his group at the center and then scales and rates everyone on the basis of it. Every society is ethnocentric upto some extent. But Anthropologist must be non-ethnocentric as much as possible. Then only one can expect fair and honest results.

Why is Culture relativism important in Anthropology ? →

(i) It explain the differences in human cultures An ethno centric view may justify racism , but cultural relativism discard racism as each culture has its own independent identity and way of living.

(ii) It promotes tolerance → Ethnic clashes between tribes can be resolved if these exist cultural relativist understanding of both cultures. [Eg] Recent crises between Meitei & Kuki in Manipur.

Case Study → Khasas of Jaunsar Bawar practise polyandry. This is because there is scarcity of resources. Marrying one woman by all brothers means less Bride price. Thus an Ethnocentric view may view this practise derogatory , but cultural relativism justifies such differences. Elizabeth Zachenter critisices cultural relativism as they promote | justify behaviours that are against dignity of humans