No man's knowledge can go beyond his experience
Aayushi Bansal, AIR 97, 2023
When Britishers arrived in India, their limited experience of Western societies, made them label India as savage and backward. As per them, it needed cultural upliftment, which they called 'White man's Burden'.
However, when they read Indian texts, conducted studies, without even directly experiencing Indian way of life, some of them realised the cultural basis of Indian society. It was a different society from West but was in no way inferior. Unfortunately this enlightenment was limited to few English men.
The above example shows how one's knowledge can be limited by our experience. However, it also shows its expansion based on one's receptiveness.
In this essay, we will examine what is meant by 'knowledge' and 'experience'. Why can't our knowledge go beyond our experience? What is its impact? How can we make our knowledge widen its horizons beyond the boundaries of direct experience and what impact this can create?
Knowledge is the repository of information which we interpret, understand and apply to solve problems of daily life. It gives the guidelines for all our actions.
Experience is one's observations, actions by oneself, actions done to oneself and the overall intelligence one accumulates due to direct observation and action.
Why is our knowledge limited to our experiences ?
First of all, there are certain things for which imagination is simply not possible. One has to directly observe and act to be able to add it to one's knowledge.
For example, Michael Phelps, world's greatest swimmer couldn't possibly have built his knowledge of swimming without actually practicing it. Similarly, one can't know the colour red by only reading about it without actually seeing it.
Further, we remember & act on knowledge which we primarily gain through experience. Dr B R Ambedkar experienced acute discrimination which built his knowledge of inequality, deprivation and exclusion. This was reflected in an egalitarian Constitution designed by him.
Neatly, real knowledge is the one which we can apply and this sense of application is built on foundations of experience.
Captain Gopinath's experience of unable to find a low cost airline helped him to apply this knowledge. The result was India's first low cost airline, Air Deccan.
What is the impact of this knowledge generated via experience ?
Firstly, one starts valuing experience over mere textual reading, Gandhiji stayed with Harijans to understand their plight and to effectively lead a campaign against atrocities.
Secondly, it generates a plethora of practical and usable knowledge which one can apply. Ideas of numerous startups like Uber, Oyo, Flipkart and so on were based on their experiences.
However, it has a flip side too. It generates a partial truth and prevents us from building a holistic understanding.
For example, a man who has experienced women servility within household, starts treating women at workplace in a similar manner unable to mend his ways.
Similarly, it restricts one's problem solving ability where one can't foresee a problem faced by others. For example, neo liberal experience of institutions like World Bank, International Monetary Fund (IMF) makes them think in a unidirectional perspective of neo liberal capitalism. It creates a problem of one size fits all.
When can our knowledge go beyond our own experiences?
Firstly, when one starts to build a knowledge base based on not only one's own but also others' experiences. Indian Constitution is a perfect example.
It learnt from all major democracies of the world like USA, United Kingdom and adopted their best practices by modifying them to suit Indian content.
Secondly, one has to expand the meaning of experience itself. It has to go beyond conventional ideas of direct observation and action. Eklavya in Mahabharata never experienced a formal teaching course on archery. However, he developed his knowledge base by changing the meaning of experience to self practice and self learning.
Neatly, one has to become receptive of criticism to gain wider view points. Buddha always patiently heard his critics. this knowledge expanded without even experiencing things directly.
Another thing to remember is to learn to apply knowledge gained via textual sources and not direct experience. Recent advancements in vaccine technology are a testimony to brilliant application.
What is the impact of this expanded knowledge?
It helps to grow the society in totality. Everyone learns more and solves problems. Seventy five years ago, the world predicted that Indian nation won't be able to survive due to its lack of experience of democracy and rampant poverty within huge diversity.
India not only conducted the world's largest elections in 1952 without previous experience of such scale but also stands strong today as a nation of world's largest democracy.
Widening our knowledge beyond experience also helps to solve problems of future. We can imagine possible causes and consequences and provide for solutions accordingly.
The whole world working together to prevent climate change is a case in point. We don't exactly know what will be the consequences if the temperature rises beyond 2°C because we haven't experienced it but we still can predict possible outcomes.
Further, broader knowledge also generates economic prosperity. When an economy begins thinking from the perspective of most vulnerable even if the policy makers haven't experienced poverty and exclusion themselves. They develop inclusive growth. Honourable Prime Minister calls this "Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikaas"
One must constantly keep adding to our storehouse of information both from our own & others' experiences, texts, architecture, historical accounts and so on. Learning from the mistakes of others before he commits one himself is the jewel of the wise.