Critically analyze the views of G.P. Murdock and others on the universality of family
Tanuj Pathak, AIR 72, 2023
GP Murdock has analysed More than 250 societies ranging from most primitive industrial societies to most industrialised one. He concluded that every society has some form of family and said family is Universal. He Gave the definition of family as - "It is a social group involving residential cohabitation, economic cooperation and reproduction. It has people of both sexes, two of whom maintain sexual relations and have children own or adopted."
Various problems in this definition →
(1) family has people of both sexes → In Black families of west Indies, Males are generally not included in the ambit of family.
(ii) Residential Cohabitation → Study by Yanina Salman of Kibbutz of Israel. Children live away from parents in a dormitory together. So there is not residential cohabitation there.
(iii) Homo Sexual families — - Azande in Africa allows male-to-male marriage and have same sex families. - Cheyenne Indians allow "Boy wives", i.e. Male-male marriages and family - Similarly, Nandi in Kenya and Nuers in Sudan allows female-female marriages and families.
(iv) Single Parent families → In developed societies, (eg) → Norway, Sweden, etc, there is an observed trend of Single Parent families. Thus, these examples show family is not universal.
② Views of Jan Trost (1991) → After analysing various families, concluded that it is very difficult to have a universal definition of family because - In her sample, for some family consisted of only nearest kins, i.e. a nuclear family. But for others family also meant distant relatives, friends and for some even pets.
(b)
(i) Views of Kathleen Gough →
After analysing Nayars of kerela and other societies, she concluded that -
family is NOT universal both structurally as well as functionally. Only Mother - Child combination is Universal, and its universal function is primary socializatai.
Contemporary relevance → In present societies there has been growth of new types of families such as Same-sex | Homosexual families, families out of Live-in relationships, etc. Thus, Anthropologists need to have a broader understanding of the institution of family.