Compare and Contrast Formalism and Substantivism as approaches to study Economic organisation.
Saichaitanya Jadhav
Formalism & Substantivism is a debate in economic anthropology that is concerned with how 'neo classical model of economy applies to simple society'.
Comparison
| Aspects | Formalism | Substantivism | |---|---|---| | Proponents | Tim goody | Herskovits, Malinowski | | Principle of Maximisation | Production multiplier | Production optimiser | | Principle of demand & supply | Followed | Not following | | Principle of rationality | Exist | Does not exist | | Type of economy | Stratified | Egalitarian | | Division of labour | clearly demarcated | Unclear | | Medium of exchange | exist | May/may not be | | Surplus | surplus based economy | No aspect of surplus | | Exchange | market based | Reciprocity |
Contrasting features
1. Both are Intra disciplinary in nature 2. Exist to explain the aspects of economy 3. One principle can be applied to any society 4. Follows core basic economic model.
Criticism
1. Plattner - Difficult to generalise both type of economy as both are getting aligned. 2. Prattis - There are no substeantivist based economy exist today
Way forward
Neo marxist school based on friedman Speaks of economy based on core principle of demand & supply exist on any type of Society should be guiding light through aspect of "Structural economic model"