Topper Copies

Compare Darwin's theory of natural selection with Lamarck's inheritance of acquired characters.

Gudelli Srujana, AIR 55, 2025

Lamarck gave the organic theory of evolution first in the Dark Age of science. Later followed by Darwin who gave on natural selection

Comparision between Darwin's and Lamarck's theories

| Darwin's theory | Lamarck's theory | |---|---| | 1. It was given in his work 'On the Origin of species by Natural selection' | 1. This theory was first given in his book 'Philosophie Zoologique' | | 2. The natural selection theory was given | 2. Under it, inheritance of acquired traits was given | | 3. According to it, due to increased struggle for survival due to population rise, natural selection operates. | 3. It says that whatever the traits that are acquired will be passed to next generation | | 4. Darwin gave that variations are present which drive the selection process. | 4. Gave theory of use and disuse. If it's used then it grows otherwise degenerates | | 5. It considered facts. | 5. It didnot consider the facts. | | 6. It gave that the survival of fittest variations is seen. | 6. It gave that every organism tends to grow as part of evolution | | Ex According to it, there were both short necked and long necked Giraffes. But the long necked ones had the advantage of reaching the branches hence they survived. | Ex According to it, the Giraffe is tall because it had to use it's neck to reach branches. Hence it's neck length is created with use. |

Criticisms

1. Mutilation experiment done disproves Lamarck's Theory of inheritance of acquired traits. - Ex:- If a person's legs were lost due to accident then his child did not born without legs. 2. Also both the theories gave without much evidences. 3. Both of them were earliest theories of evolution 4. Lamarck ignores the population level changes. Darwin ignores individual level changes.

Lamarckism has been later completely ignored. Darwin's theory formed further basis of synthetic theory of evolution.