Examine the various hypotheses about the decline of the Indus Valley Civilization. What are the strengths and weaknesses of each hypothesis?
Gudelli Srujana, AIR 55, 2025
Indus valley civilization belonged to the Chalcolithic period in the sub continent. There are many theories given for it's decline.
Hypotheses about decline of Indus Valley Civilization
1. Suicidal weakness theory
- (i) It says that due to lack of adaptability of the Harappans their culture declined. - (ii) Despite regular flooding of the Indus river, they neither shifted to new place nor built structures that could withstand floods. - (iii) It was given by Marshall and Mackay based on the Mohejodaro remains.
Strengths - 1. It talked about culture stagnation - 2. It also mentioned evidence found at Mohenjodaro.
Weakness - 1. It is based on only one site. - 2. It is considered as speculative.
2. Invasion theory
- (i) It says that Aryans invaded and that led to fight with the locals. - (ii) Literary evidence was given by Max Muller where in Rig Veda was cited. - (iii) Linguistic evidence was given by William Jones - similarity between languages with West Asia. - (iv) Archaeological evidence as cited by Mortimer Wheeler where at Mohenjodaro broken bones were found.
Strengths - 1. It talks with evidence. - 2. Also gave a reason why broken bones are discovered.
Weakness - 1. Indigenous Aryan theory was proposed. - 2. There is no significant genetic similarity.
3. Degeneration theory
- (i) It says that the civilization was declined due to lack of adaptation to climate change. - (ii) Also when the population growth increased, enough food was not produced. - (iii) This caused the degeneration with deaths.
Strengths - (1) It brought how climate change can affect the civilization - (2) It is relevant in understanding the Malthusian theory on population growth.
Weakness - (1) This hypothesis is considered as speculative. - (2) No evidences were given.
4. Natural calamities theories
- (i) The River vagaries theory says that due to the vagaries in Indus River, the civilization was destroyed. - (ii) Back lighting theory says that the presence of charred bones indicate that sudden physico - chemical reactions led to the decline. - (iii) The Hydrological theory says that due to flooding by Indus river the culture was declined.
Strengths - 1. Linked the scientific phenomena to culture degeneration. - 2. It also brought how the civilization gets affected with climate change.
Weakness - 1. No solid evidence presented for back lighting theory - 2. Drawing general conclusions as the civilization was on the banks of river Indus.
Though these theories have criticisms, they gave multi-dimensional view to understand degeneration of the culture.