Topper Copies

Critically evaluate Forest laws of Indian government post-independence. Also explain how has 'Shifting Cultivation' emerged as a significant point of contention in tribal development and forest policy?

Gudelli Srujana, AIR 55, 2025

Post- independence, forest laws in India saw a shift from resource oriented to rights approach.

Forest laws of Indian government post-independence

1. forest policy of 1952 focussed on timber extraction from forest. 2. Wildlife Protection Act, 1972 to protect the flora and fauna. 3. Environment Protection Act,1986. 4. forest policy of 1988 has seen a shift where it recognized the role of tribals in forest conservation. 5. forest conservation Act, 1980. 6. Forest Rights Act, 2006 gave first time rights to forest dwelling communities.

Impact of forest laws in tribal development

Positive impact

1. Recognition of rights of tribals. 2. Administrative support for tribal development. 3. Legal protection to tribes dwelling in forests. 4. Ownership and control of forests by tribal communities. 5. Gram Sabha became crucial in decentralised decision making.

Criticisms

1. Gram Sabha authority is sidelined. - Ex: Consent not taken in constructing loker dam in chattisgarh. 2. The highhandedness of forest bureaucracy. - Ex: In Chattisgarh, the community forest rights determined by forest department. 3. conflicts between tribals and bureaucracy. - Ex: Killing of forest officer by Guttikoyas in Telangana. 4. Declaration of Protected Areas affecting the grazing rights.

Shifting cultivation a point of contention

1. It is a technique where a forest patch is cleared and farming is done. After harvest, that patch is abandoned and new patch is cleared. 2. It is done in annual cycles. 3. It leads to deforestation thus directly at conflict with forest department. - Ex: Jhum cultivation in North east 4. It also leads to forest fires. - Ex: Podu cultivation - forest fires in Chattisgarh. 5. The resource crunch and pollution is another issue.

Suggestions

1. Train Tribals on sustainable practices of shifting cultivation. - Ex: Vermi composting use in Chattisgarh 2. Terrace cultivation in Northeast. - Ex: In Arunachal Pradesh 3. focus on carbon sequestration. - Ex: Alder tree method among the Nagas. 4. Reduce the number of cycles of cultivation per year.

The laws should be implemented properly and should evolve according to needs. Draft National Forest Policy of 2018 should be passed addressing the existing loopholes.