Critically analyse the Impact of Modern Democratic Institutions on Tribal areas.
Gudelli Srujana, AIR 55, 2025
Based on the recommendations of Dhebar commission, PESA, 1996 (Panchayat Raj Extension to scheduled Areas) was enacted.
Impact of Modern democratic institutions on tribal areas
POSITIVE IMPACT
1. Empowerment of tribals by giving them rights - Ex: FRA, 2006 gave them habitat rights 2. Acted as a tool to assert their rights. - Ex: Gram sabhas of Bami grasslands - Maldharis passed resolution to restore their rights. 3. To counter land alienation and unwanted industrialization. - Ex: Against Posco steel company tribes of Odisha formed an association. 4. To collect the natural resources for their subsistent economy. - Ex: In chattisgarh, tendu leaves collection of tribes. 5. Gave autonomy to preserve their culture. - Ex: Autonomous District councils under VI schedule in Assam, etc
CASE STUDY Pathalgadi movement in Jharkhand. with the efforts of B.D. Sharma and Bandi Oraon, tribes become aware of their rights. They erected Megaliths with inscriptions of provisions of FRA, 2006 and Supreme court judgements.
CRITICISMS
1. The consent of tribes was ignored in many cases. (Xaxa Committee Report) - Ex: In Polavaram dam, the Gramsabha consent was faked. 2. Entry of outsiders and dominating their gram sabhas politically. - Ex: Among Santhals of Jharkhand. 3. Women and children have become victims of displacement. - Ex: Sexual exploitation of women in Rehabilitation centres. 4. Xaxa committee also highlighted the administrative apathy in implementing policies.
Recommendations
1. Awareness of rights among tribal communities is needed. 2. B.D. Sharma gave a triangular model of development where, tribal interests, national needs and the regional interests should be considered.
Bandhopadhyaya committee studied the issues of democratic institutions among tribes and suggested empathetic administration is needed.