Topper Copies

Compare and contrast Classical evolutionism and Neo-evolutionism as Theoretical perspectives in anthropology. How did the neo-evolutionist perspective build upon it and critique the earlier classical evolutionist theories.

Saichaitanya Jadhav

Classical evolutionary school of thought was propounded in late 19th century which entailed the aspect of tracing evolution of various attributes of culture. Whereas Neo evolutionism is an updated version evolved upon the critique of Evolutionary school of thought by various thinkers.

Comparison of both school

| | Classical evolutionism | Neo evolutionism | |---|---|---| | Time period | Late 19th century | 20th century | | Proponents | E.B. Taylor, L H Morgan, James Frazer | J. Steward, L. White, R. Linton | | Methodology | Secondary source of Information, Imagination | Fieldwork, first hand data | | Psychic unity of mankind | Yes | No | | Direction of evolution | Unilinear [a stepped upward drawing labelled civilization, Barbarism, Savagery] | Parabolic [an upward arrow and a parabolic curve] | | Conjecturalism | Yes | No | | Types of evolution | Unilinear | Unilinear, Universal, Multi linear | | Complexity | Simple | Complex | | Interelation of Culture | No | Yes (Cultural ecology) | | | Ethnocentrism | Cultural Relativism |

Contrasting | similarity features

1. Both showed the direction of evolution of various institutions 2. Both used Synchronic studies 3. L.H.Morgan did fieldwork in Todas while all Neoevolutionary did too 4. Both depict human energy & adaptability as force for evolution.

Neo evolutionist perspective build upon it

1. Using various fieldwork expedition done by proponents 2. Enabled specific culture has their respective evolutionary characteristics 3. Influenced by school of historical particularism to collect data & historical aspect 4. Through analysing interelation of culture with technology, environment etc.-

Neoevolutionism build upon critique of Classical evolutionism

1. Rejected the aspect of parallelism, Conjecturalism 2. trabled them to work upon the fieldwork which was not performed earlier 3. Criticised Ethno-centric approach of them 4. Rejecting Psychic Unity of Mankind Concept 5. Following approach of Multiple origin of Culture with collection of data

therefore Neoevolutionist theory brought up by critcizing classical evolutionist but it inspired from the later in many ways