Compare and contrast the contributions of Bronislaw Malinowski and Raymond C. Brown to Anthropological thought. Discuss their theoretical perspectives, fieldwork methodologies, and key contributions to the discipline.
Saichaitanya Jadhav
Bronislaw Malinowski and R.C. Brown are proponents of functional & structural functional school of thought. respectively. They emerged in reaction to Diffusionism & Classical evolutionism.
Comparison of both
| | Malinowski | R.C. Brown | |---|---|---| | Timeperiod | Early 20th century | Mid 20th century | | School | functionalism | Structural functionalism | | Fieldwork | Trobriander Island, Papa new guinea | Andaman Islands, India | | Focus | Culture | Society | | Concept | Individual needs | Societal needs | | Aspect | Various Institution exist to fulfill the needs of individual | Individual perform functions to maintain the society to work | | Analogy | Charter of Malinowski | Organic Analogy |
Constrast / Similarities of both
1. Both focused on functional aspect of Institution 2. Both significantly perceived extensive fieldwork 3. Both used Diachronic Study 4. Both are criticised for showing Institution as Static & not discussing conflict aspect. 5. Both perceived their school of thought in reaction to evolutionary scheme
Theoretical perspectives
Both Malinowski & Brown relied on similar perspective as -> a) Every Institution has parts of in it b) Every parts are Interrelated, Inter dependent, Integrated c) Any one part of it get diffused leading to effect on all d) Combination of function of all parts lead to structure being intact.
fieldwork methodologies
Malinowski -> Performed Participant Observation method by staying in Trobriander Island for >2 years -> Also he employed various methods Such as case study, Questionnaire, Schedule etc
Brown -> Persued fieldwork in Andaman Islands -> He is first to use Questionnaire method -> He also employed Genealogical method -In work
Key Contributions
Malinowski -> (a) charter of Institution -
fig. Charter of Institution | Individual in performing function
(b) Needs - In his work "scientific theory of Needs' gave 3 types of needs - Primary | Biological - symbolic Integrative - secondary | derivative
Brown - (a) Social System consist of 3 types of aspects - Ecological aspect, Cultural aspect, Technological aspect
(b) He also devised contribution in various fields like kinship, Religion etc
Therefore both made anthropology as holistic discipline which inspired future generation of anthropologist