The principle of impartiality may conflict with the need for compassion towards marginalized communities. Discuss in the context of civil services in India.
Ishan Bhatnagar, AIR 5, 2025
Impartiality refers to performing one's duty without fear or favour, and not discriminating against anyone. Sardar Patel called it one of the founding pillars of the bureaucracy.
Conflict with compassion towards the marginalized
1. Taking no side -> strong prevail over the weak: matsyanyaya. 2. Sometimes compensatory discrimination is needed for redressing historical injustice -> logic for affirmative action. 3. Violates Rawlsian Difference Principle that system should benefit the least well off. 4. Undermines welfare vision of Indian state to wipe "every tear from every eye".
Impartiality also supports compassion
1. Upholding rule of law -> ensuring justice to victims, marginalized. eg> IPS officer pursuing rape charges even against powerful actors. 2. Taking decisions fairly -> open competition, giving chance to underprivileged. eg> UPSC. 3. Creating efficient systems -> matters of the vulnerable sections also taken up.
Hence there is a need for Harmonious Reading of the two values for civil servants where they must follow Procedural impartiality while also ensuring Substantive justice to the marginalized, through compassion.