The Descent and Alliance Theories are two distinct yet complimentary strategies in understanding Kinship and Social Structure. Analyse.
Saichaitanya Jadhav
As per Abercrombie, kinship refers to relationship of persons based on blood (Consanguinious) or Marriage (Affinal). Thus explanation of kinship is based on two school of thought -> Descent Theory (Evans pitchard, Radcliffe Brown) -> Alliance theory (Levi strauss)
Descent & Alliance theory ⇒ Distinct in understanding kinship & social structure
1. Descent theory - main proponents were Evans pitchard, Radcliffe Brown. - It speaks descent based on arrangement of persons in a group such that lineage is traced through either of line Consanguinally - As per theory, Main Jural authority of person leads to trace their descent with respective to their line
for example, In patrilocal residence Jural / Political authority -> Father kinship ----> Father-line However there can be exception with regards to Ambilineality descent. - They explain kinship based on roles of descent in terms of Unilineal Descent, Bilineal descent, Ambilineal descent, Parallel descent, cross descent, Bilateral descent - Descent theory also explains Social structure through concepts such as Descent groups, (lineage, Clan, phratery, Moiety based group) Filiation / complimentary filiation and rules of marriage (Prescribed, prescribed &preferential) - Radcliffe Brown in African kinship system too support Descent Theory
2. Alliance Theory -> where levi strauss speaks of 3 types of Exchange -> Goods & Service, Ideas, Humans - As Goods & Service & Ideas are common in every society, Humans exchange is the basis of kinship. - He explains kinship based on universality of Incest taboo principle
- He also explains social structure based on various exchange system a) Symmetrical Exchange - Exchange of women in same generation b) Assymmetrical -> Continous (same direction), -> Discontinous (Different direction)
Descent & Alliance theory -> Complimentary Strategies - Both explains the theoritical explation of kinship system - Kinship terminology is based on factors of both Descent & Alliance theory - Functionality of kinship in tracing descent, regulating marriage, maintaing social behaviour depends on the pillar of Descent & Alliance theory.
Therefore as per modern theory, Descent theory evolved into alliance theory and present day kinship is moving towards Kindred / Bilateral / Ego based system negating earlier two theories which confines itself to evolutionary & structural concept-