Rather than dreaming up large, all-encompassing theories Boas wanted to put the discipline on a sound inductive footing. Comment.
Gudelli Srujana, AIR 55, 2025
Franz Boas belong to Historical Particularism school of anthropological thought. It was brought as a reaction to classical evolutionism.
Historical particularism by Franz Boas 1. Franz Boas, according to him, the culture can be understood studying it's past. 2. For studying past, he gave four field method -
fig: four field method 3. Unlike earlier classical evolutionists who proposed unilinear evolution, Boas accepted multilineal evolution of culture. 4. Franz Boas deviating from earlier, accepted the role of ecology in culture adaptation. Ex (case study): franz Boas studied the long headed and round headed immigrants of Europe, he found that their children don't have such differences. This shows the ecological role in shaping culture 5. He used inductive method, where he applied his theory to a specific culture. Ex: In study of Inuits of Baffin Bay. 6. He was proponent of extensive fieldwork, with Participant observation. Ex: He studied the Tsimshian folktales and said that there are variations of same story in 24 societies. 7. franz Boas used trait listing method to study specific cultures.
Significance 1. Cultural relativistic approach in fieldwork of anthropology. 2. Accepted multiple evolutions and also diffusion of culture traits. 3. Inspired other anthropologists. Ex: his students Ruth Benedict, Margaret Mead, etc.
Criticism 1. Too much emphasis on fieldwork, lacking general theories. 2. Ignored comparative method, says Radcliffe Brown. 3. Too much emphasis on past rather than on present, criticized by post modernists.
Franz Boas turned the anthropological studies towards cultural relativism, which brought the subjectivity needed in understanding culture evolution.