How does cultural materialism explain seemingly irrational practices in traditional societies? Use Harris's ethnographic case studies.
Gudelli Srujana, AIR 55, 2025
Cultural materialism was putforward by Marvin Harris. According to it, the technology determines the social structure.
Cultural materialism 1. It says that in every culture, there are modes of production and modes of reproduction.
2. Also culture consists of three parts, namely - infrastructure, structure and superstructure.
[three concentric circles, outside to inside: superstructure (Ex: Ideals, belief, etc), structure (Ex: Family, marriage etc.), Infrastructure (Ex: Technology, etc.)]
3. Marvin Harris says that, infrastructure determines structure and superstructure. 4. This shows how culture change occurs due to infrastructure. 5. This technology determinism is similar to Leslie White's culture evolution model. 6. Marvin Harris also differentiated etic and emic views, which were coined by Kenneth Pike. Ex: Use of etic view - means outsider's view. 7. Marvin Harris used scientific methodology thus emphasizing on objectivity in research.
Case study: Sacred cow myth in India According to cultural materialism, killing of cow is banned in India because of it's material benefits. Cow gives milk, it's dung is used as fuel. Some lower social groups eat the cow meat, which addresses malnutrition problem. Due to these benefits, such practices are followed. The material needs influence belief system.
8. Marvin Harris also mentioned how the dietary habits are shaped in West Asia.
Case study In West Asia, pig meat is not consumed because they are less domesticated in these regions. It is said by Harris that as pigs eat nuts,fruits,etc. they are in direct competition with humans. Other animals like goat, sheep,etc. eat plants hence are domesticated there.
Significance 1. Cultural materialism brought objectivity in the research. 2. Also the etic view was used by Marvin Harris to study societies. 3. Scientific methodology was emphasized. Ex: Technology determinism by Marvin Harris. 4. He also focussed on the culture adaptation, where different parts of culture change according to infrastructure.
Criticisms 1. Roy Rappaport said Marvin Harris neglected religion role in the society. 2. Too much emphasis on objectivity. 3. Etic view poses the risk of ethnocentrism. 4. Post modernists criticized that the interpretation varies, which is not absolute.
Though there are criticisms, Marvin Harris deviated from earlier crude comparative methods. Thereby bringing an empirical fieldwork in anthropology.