Structural-functionalism vs Structuralism
Gudelli Srujana, AIR 55, 2025
Structural functionalism says that society should work to maintain the social structures. Structuralism says that culture comprises of structural elements in the human mind.
Structural functionalism vs. Structuralism
| Structural functionalism | Structuralism | |---|---| | 1. Gave social structure as an arrangement of individuals with specific roles with respect to each other | 1. Gave the structural part of the culture is in form of binary oppositions | | 2. Major proponents are Radcliffe Brown. | 2. Major proponents are Levi Strauss, Edmund Leach. | | 3. According to it, descent / blood ties are important. | 3. According to it, marriage has the primary role. | | 4. Gave Descent theory of marriage | 4. Gave alliance theory of marriage. | | 5. According to it, marriage is less important than unilineal descent. | 5. Marriage as the form of exchange of women as gift between two groups (binary oppositions). | | 6. Considers incest taboo as negative aspect. Because it forces to look outside the group. | 6. Considers incest Taboo as a positive aspect. Because of which peaceful ties can be established with other group. | | 7. Deviation from established social norms may lead to punishment. Ex: If caste endogamy is not followed then it attracts some form of punishment. | 7. Edmund Leach gave the concept of mediation view between the binary oppositions. Ex: Among Kachins of Burma, follow Gumsa, a mediation between Gumlao and Shan. |
Both gave an emphasis on the structural aspect of culture through intensive fieldwork.