The consequences of ethical actions are shaped by the intent behind them, but good intentions may lead to unintended harm. Examine this statement with suitable examples. Is it correct to decide rightness or wrongness of an act by looking at the intention of the person who carries it out?
Akshit Bhardwaj, AIR 12, 2025
The Doctrine of Double Effect says that actions with good intentions can sometimes cause unintended harm.
eg: Robert Oppenheimer built the Nuclear Bomb to end the war & save American lives. However it lead to lakhs of deaths in Hiroshima & Nagasaki.
In some ways it is correct to judge rightfulness by intent 1. Uncertainty of outcomes can mean intent is the best judge 2. If actions are taken in good faith they pass the test of conscience 3. If good intent aligns with duty it is in line with Kant's Deontology
However in some cases intent is not the best judge 1. Where the negative impacts are obvious & foreseeable 2. When it does not lead to good outcomes for maximum people (Utilitarian idea) 3. When intent is used as a loophole to bypass moral obligations
Thus instead of a pedantic basket of rules, rational tests based on situational ethics (Fletcher) must be used.