Topper Copies

Ghurye-Elwin debate on tribe

Gudelli Srujana, AIR 55, 2025

G.S.Ghurye suggested assimilationist approach towards tribals. Verrier Elwin gave isolationist approach- National Park approach for tribal development.

Ghurye- Elwin debate

1. Ghurye considers tribes as backward hindus. He suggested that tribes should be included in mainstream. 2. Ghurye thought this would lead to trickle down effect where tribals also gain benefits of government policies. 3. On the other hand after studying the NEFA region, Elwin suggested that they should be kept isolated. 4. Elwin said their unique culture should be preserved and that should be protected by the government. 5. If Ghurye approach is followed it would lead to marginalisation of tribes. 6. If Elwin's approach is followed, tribes remain out of government reach. may affect national solidarity.

Present state of Debate

Nehru gave integration approach where 1. The tribals are given constitutional protection and autonomy. - Ex: V and VI schedule areas. 2. Also they are given the benefits of government policy bringing under it's ambit.

Today integration approach is followed where their culture is also protected. It helped in acknowledging the tribal rights - for example, FRA, 2006.