The ultimate measure of a man is not where he stands in moments of comfort and convenience but where he stands at times of challenge & controversy.
Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024
When you look around a typical urban skyline, what do you see? A cluster of unimpressive cuboidal towers would be the most common answer. Most architects today relish the ease of standardised construction. But there was one who rejected the convenience of orthogonality, Zaha Hadid. She came up with an entirely new visual vocabulary of parametric architecture, challenging the right angles with fluid curves. Her audacity won her the coveted Pritzker Price.
She could have conformed to the mainstream, but she challenged it facing even controversy for her eccentric style. This was because to her "If it was easy, everybody would it" and this courage was her true & ultimate measure as a woman & architect.
Comfort & Convenience offer us peace. Challenge & controversy on the other hand question are very being. While the former soothes us, the later threaten us. But both present to us the unique ways in which people choose to deal with these situations.
In this essay we shall explore why comfortable & convenient situations are not the best judge of character, why challenges & controversy can a better indicator. Why some people fail to even thrive in comfort and how to ensure we are able to withstand challenges.
Comfort & Convenience: A faulty metric
Comfort & Convenience breed surplus. In such situations one has no dearth of resources, guidance & support from others. The environment is highly conducive and enabling. The stage is basically set for sure shot success. India's colonial conquest by the British is an excellent example. Colonialsm was made possible by fall of mughals, infighting amongst rulers, deep divisions in the society, and the impetus offered by industrial revolution in Britain.
Comfort & Convenience thus don't leave much for speculation, limiting their ability in assessing a person. Another issue with them is their exclusive access. Not all of us are born with a silver spoon in our mouth. In India, the top 1% of people corner 40% of the wealth, clearly the bottom 99% do not enjoy the same comforts as the bourgeois. This discrepancy erodes credibility of comfort & convenience to judge people who don't even have access to them.
Challenges & Controversies: The real battle
Challenges & controversies require us to overcome obstacles. Often these obstacles are designed to retard our progress and stifle our spirit. It takes immense courage to tear down these obstacles, which is representative of a strong character. Malala Yousafzai overcame Taliban's threats against her life and fought for education for women, her bravery even earned her a Nobel Peace Prize.
Challenges & Controversies represent a scarcity situation. In the absence of requisite resources, people are forced to work under highly stressful situations. And those who withstand such adverse conditions emerge as true winners. In 1991 India was burdened with the twin deficit problem, the GoI's novel LPG reforms not only saved our economy but paved way for us to become the 5th largest economy globally in three decades.
Challenges are ruthless, they spare no one. Often times these challenges are posed by our loved ones making matters even worse. But those who are able to morally defend themselves even against their family & loved ones are truly remarkable beings. In Ramayana, Vibhishan tries to reason with Ravana, but when his brother refuses to see the light, he bravely holds his ground and instead sides with Lord Rama.
Controversies have inherent latent costs. They cost people their respect, a value that is built over a time. Controversies attack directly at one's credibility, causing us moral discomfort. Those bravehearts that are able to dismiss controversies through their willpower and effort are able to redeem themselves and show their true value as a person. Cricketer Hardik Pandaya faced many controversies during IPL 2024, but through his hardwork was not only able to gain back his respect & support from fans, but also enabled India to lift the T20 World Cup after 14 years.
Challenges curate a restrictive environment. One where people don't have faith in your abilities, they don't trust you, they discredit & dismiss you and they even deny you an opportunity to prove them wrong. But despite such odds, when a person is able to thrive & succeed, it speaks volumes about his character. Famous industrialist, Mr Sreekant Bhola, co-founder of Bolant Industries faced such hardships due to his visual impairness and yet succeeded, making him truly an inspiration.
Challenges & controversies in addition to being restrictive also create situations wherein where no available choice is without vice. There is no clear cut right solution, and a choice has to be made between lesser of the two devils. Developing countries today are forced to choose between development and environmental conservation. And yet when countries like India emerge as top performers amongst G20 cohort on the Climate Performance Index it is truly remarkable.
To deal with challenges & controversies requires great courage for it often involves trying to change a deep rooted status quo. People in order to protect status quo, go to great lengths in destroying even noble attempts towards reformation. Raja Ram Mohan Roy dared to challenge the social evils facing backlash from traditionalists. His zeal for reformation despite challenges immortalised his persona.
Thus challenges & controversies and not comfort & convenience are the ultimate measure of a man. But interestingly, sometimes some people are not able to thrive even in the most comfortable situations. Consider Midas, a wealthy king who was bestowed with the golden touch. Instead of prosperity, Midas doomed owing to his greed.
In other situations people start taking comfort & convenience for granted. The meteoric rise & fall of Kingfisher under Vijay Mallaya is cautionary tale against extravagance & overindulgance.
Challenge & Controversy Proofing
Comforts & Conveniences may be exclusionary but challenges & controversies are highly inclusive. They trouble everybody. Rich/poor, young/old everybody has to face challenges & controversies at least once in their life. So it is imperative that we build the ability to not only withstand challenges but also thrive against them.
To ensure we are not carried away by the winds of challenges, we must have a strong moral foundation to anchor us firmly. The New Education Policy (2020) thrust on value based education is a step in the right direction to nurture kids who will become ethical adults later.
To deal with challenges we must resist negativity & failure biases. Instead of catastrophising the situation we should focus on finding solutions by developing a positive mindset. An inspiration in this regard is JK Rowling who did not give up when 12 publishers turned down her Harry Potter manuscripts.
Challenges & Controversies are confusing. To solve these mysteries we need to develop creative out of the box thinking abilities. When the world came to a halt during the lockdown, businesses devised the Work From Home model to deal with the crisis.
Therefore in life the true measure of a person is not gauged by how well he enjoys his comfort & conveniences. Almost everybody, if given the chance could do that. But, it is measured by how well a person is able to withstand challenges & controversies and emerge unscathed & victorious.
Just like the true measure of Arjuna was not how he reigned in peace, but how he sided with dharma in the battlefield. We too should be inspired to quash any challenges which come our way and be the best versions of ourselves.