“Objectivity in anthropological fieldwork is both essential and elusive.” Critically discuss with examples.
Gudelli Srujana, AIR 55, 2025
Objectivity in anthropological fieldwork was brought in post-modern period.
SIGNIFICANCE OF OBJECTIVITY IN ANTHROPOLOGICAL FIELDWORK 1. It helps in understanding the cultures as it is. Ex> Through interviews, etc. 2. Reduces the bias of the researcher in studying cultures. Ex> Recording the covert behaviours like underground mafia, etc. 3. It is based on rationality. Ex> Clifford Geertz study on Balinese cockfights. 4. To understand how different materials are important across cultures. Ex> Cognitive anthropology - study by Taylor among Koyas - seven different varieties of bamboo present.
WHY IT IS ELUSIVE? 1. According to post-modernists, there is no single truth. 2. Also the influence of the researcher's values system on the studies may turn it into biased view. 3. Jacques Derrida's deconstruction of idea says there can be multiple interpretations for a text. 4. Ignoring how individual agency influence the social structures. Ex => Symbolic interactionism. 5. The dynamics of power as mentioned by Michel Foucault was not considered. 6. Thus it makes the fieldwork being objective may be ethnocentric to other researcher.
MEASURES REQUIRED 1. Triangulation of data should be followed. Ex Cora du Bois study on Alorese - collecting three different types of data and gave it to different researchers. 2. Reflexivity should be promoted in the fieldwork. Ex Anthropologist recording his/her own thoughts during research. 3. Cultural relativism should be followed. Ex Participant Rural Appraisal.
Objectivity sometimes also leads to violation of human rights - recording derogatory practices followed in society by the researcher. So, the studies done should be sensible enough to know how the data is recorded.