Fieldwork has been central to anthropology, but it is not a static tradition. Critically examine the evolution of fieldwork traditions with respect to changing ethical, technological, and socio-political contexts.
Gudelli Srujana, AIR 55, 2025
fieldwork refers to the study of the cultures of societies in their native ecosystem. It was first started by L.H. Morgan
SIGNIFICANCE OF FIELDWORK IN ANTHROPOLOGY
fig: significance of fieldwork
EVOLUTION OF FIELDWORK TRADITION (A) Classical evolutionism 1. Under this thought, mostly anthropologist relied on secondary sources of data. Ex E.B.Tylor - 2. They are ethnocentric - tried to look culture through lens of researches. Ex L.H.Morgan on Iroquois. 3. They are called called as positivists - applying general laws to all cultures.
(B) During colonialism 1. Verandah method is used to collect the data. Ex Radcliffe Brown in Andamans. 2. Also used to justify race concept - did scientific studies. Ex Eugene Fischer's measurment of human brains in Africans.
(C) Participant observation 1. It was first used by Franz Boas. Ex In studying Inuits, Kwakiutl, etc. 2. It brought cultural relativistic approach to fieldwork studies. Ex) Malinowski's study among the Trobriand islanders. 3. Emic view was brought. Ex) Marvin Harris, Conklin's ethnosemantics in Hanunoo.
(D) Post modernism 1. The fieldwork tradition took a shift by bringing Reflexivity. Ex) Autoethnography. 2. Also the field has changed from simple to complex societies. Ex) Netnography.
CRITICISMS PRESENT 1. Too much emphasis by the evolutionists on scientific principles was criticized by Franz Boas. Ex) Psychic unity of mankind 2. Ignoring the influence of religion by Marvin Harris was criticized by Roy Rappaport. 3. The post-modernists criticize the validity of an anthropologist as an interpreter. Ex) Clifford Geertz on Hermeneutics. 4. Also Jacques Derrida's idea of deconstruction questions the anthropologist's theories. Ex) There can be different interpretations for a single text.
Though there are few criticisms, the fieldwork has become dynamic changing according to societies. "A field is what to an anthropologist is like a lab to a scientist."