Topper Copies

How do descent theories and alliance theories differ in their approaches to understanding kinship and social organization?

Gudelli Srujana, AIR 55, 2025

Descent Theory was given by Radcliffe Brown (Structural functionalist) whereas Alliance theory was given by Levi Strauss (structuralist).

Differences between Descent and Alliance theories

| Descent theory | Alliance theory | |---|---| | 1. According to this, blood ties are more important. | 1. This theory says that marriage is important | | 2. Considers unilineal descent important and marriage as secondary. | 2. Considers marriage as the primary institution. | | 3. Meyer fortes gave the concept of filiation - where identity of a child derives from parents. | 3. Levi Strauss under binary oppositions, considers exchange of women as highest form of gift | | 4. And under filiation, the legal relations like inheritance of property can be derived from any one of the parent. | 4. Between two groups, to maintain peace, exchange takes place in the form of words, goods and services, women. | | 5. Considers incest taboo as a negative aspect. | 5. Considers incest taboo as a positive aspect. | | 6. Because of incest taboo, an individual is forced look for mate outside the group. | 6. Because of incest taboo, marriage relations can be maintained between two groups. It thus creates a generation of peaceful federations. | | 7. Social organisation is based on the blood ties in stronger. | 7. Social organisation based on exchange between groups brings stability. |

Criticisms

1. Alliance theory neglected how the blood ties play an important relations between groups. 2. Descent theory ignored marriage as a means in providing social stability. 3. Radcliffe Brown considered unilineal descent only - "Blood is thicker than water." 4. But in new age, kinship is considered based on fluid relations. - Ex: Janet Carsten's concept of "relatedness" - where kinship ties are based on social construct.

David schneider also gave the change in kinship terms in his work "American kinship" where even ART therapies, LGBQT relations, surrogacy, etc. are also considered in shaping kinship ties.