Discuss the 'Nature-Culture Dichotomy' and its critical examination in contemporary anthropology.
Gudelli Srujana, AIR 55, 2025
According to the Nature - Culture dichotomy, Nature proponents believe that everything is made by God. Culture proponents believe that man created the culture.
Nature - culture dichotomy
1. Classical anthropologists supported the version that Nature is already present. It supports the culture. - Ex: E.B.Tylor, Frazer, etc. 2. Later considering the variations in culture across many societies, it was observed that independent inventions were possible. - Ex: Multilineal evolution of culture. 3. The proponents of the nature are also called as positivists. 4. Positivists are those who try to understand culture as a pattern - scientific laws applied. 5. whereas the culture version supports that independent cultures are present when we see culture through lens of natives. - Ex: Culture relativism
Relevance in Anthropology
1. It gives different interpretations on origin of cultures. 2. It also shows how the colonialism influenced anthropology. - Ex: Positivism. 3. It shows the evolution of anthropology. - Ex: From ethnocentric to cultural relativistic.
Criticisms
1. The entry of fieldwork traditions countered the narrative of classical evolutionists. - Ex: Participant observation method. 2. Post-modernists say that it lies in the eyes of the researcher. - Ex: The belief system of the anthropologists also affect the study.
Case study
Malinowski - Functionalist, studied Trobriand islanders. He stayed with them for 31 months and participant observed culture - participant observation. But he was criticized that there can be possibility of Hawthorne effect - where the natives behave differently in presence of outsiders.
3. The rigid classification of the Nature and culture was overruled by modern anthropologists. - Ex: Jacques Derrida's idea that there can be different meanings. 4. Culture proponents saying that humans created everything - shows humans as more creative. 5. Ignorance of the general theories may not contribute to the theoretical development of anthropology. - Ex: Proponents of culture. 6. Belief of psychic unity of mankind was countered by including concept of ecological adaptation.
It is the mix of both Nature and culture that helps us understand the culture the way it is - micro and macro theories.