How does Durkheim's idea of sacred and profane provides an alternative to secularization thesis.
Gudelli Srujana, AIR 55, 2025
Durkheim says that religion comprises set of things which are considered as sacred, kept apart and invoke a sense of respect in individuals. Secularization thesis says that as the society becomes advanced, the role of religion reduces and the role of science and rationality increases.
Durkheim's idea of sacred and profane as alternative to secularization thesis 1. Durkheims says that religion is eternal. 2. It just transforms itself even in the advanced societies. 3. He says the old sacred gets replaced with new sacred items. 4. He counters secularization thesis saying that religion and science are not mutually exclusive 5. Even in case of a scientist, a lab and other equipments used are sacred things. 6. It focuses on the utility of sacred things. Ex: The utility of an object to an individual determines whether it is sacred or profane. 7. This gives a view that religion need not be associated always with supernatural beings. 8. Also Durkheim's argues idea of sacred and profane is needed in every society.
Criticisms 1. Creating a rigid classification of into Sacred and profane. 2. Also ignored the concept of Atheism in religion. 3. Post modernists say that religion has become a private matter of an individual. 4. The replacement of religion with Science as society advances, proposed by frazer was ignored. 5. Symbolic theory - Geertz considers religion as part of culture not a separate entity.
Though there are few setbacks, Durkheim's idea of sacred and profane of religion gives a view that religion evolves over time with the advancement of science.