Critically evaluate the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis in the light of contemporary linguistic anthropology.
Gudelli Srujana, AIR 55, 2025
Sapir-Whorf hypothesis Sapir -Whorf hypothesis says that language also influences the culture. It was given by Edward Sapir and Benjamin lee Whorf:
[a diagram]
- Usually culture influences the language Ex: Sociolect, dialect, etc. - But reverse was proposed.
[a diagram]
1. Study was done among three languages Finnish, English and Hebrew. It was found that Finnish follow m-time schedule. They give importance to the cultural ties than other two languages. 2. Between the Hopi and English languages, in English, more tenses are present which is not present in Hopi. Also Hopi's language has discreet terms. for example, they give directions based on the river flow. whereas in English - East, West, North and South directions are present. Thus making English as a complex and language where more importance to the time. 3. Study was done between Navajos and English speaking sample. The Navajos had importance to shape and color of an object, when shown a rope, of different colors, they identified with the shape. 4. In Mayan and English languages, it was found that Mayans don't give importance to the number of articles. Thus ambiguity is allowed unlike in English, which is very specific. 5. In Japanese language, they have different words based on gender. Thus children develop gender sensitivity at young age itself.
Criticisms of Sapir Whorf hypothesis 1. It didn't put emphasis on the aspects like code switching. It makes language flexible. 2. Also the concept of Double speak, where individuals change language is not considered. 3. Post- modernists argue that these kind of generalistic statements donot apply to the cultures across world. Ex: There is no absolute truth. 4. Conklin gave ethnosemantics concept where the language acts as an important link between the culture and human mind. Ex: Hanunoo colour categories to identify various plants and animals. 5. The interpretation may be biased due to researchers' own value system. Reflexivity was suggested in the fieldwork tradition. 6. Comparison of the simple societies with the advanced societies itself is flawed because each society has a unique culture. And it should be understood in it's own way.
Though there are criticisms, Sapir Whorf hypothesis has brought a change in understanding the dynamics of language in culture.