Topper Copies

Mariyam, a talented and driven engineer, was recently hired at XYZ Corp, a well-known manufacturing company with a predominantly male workforce. This job was a significant achievement for Mariyam, as it offered a good salary that supports her and her family financially. Initially excited about her new role, Mariyam's enthusiasm quickly faded as she began experiencing sexual harassment from several colleagues. The harassment ranged from inappropriate comments about her appearance to unwanted advances and suggestive messages. Mariyam occasionally confided to her direct supervisor about these incidents, but he dismissed her concerns, suggesting she view these comments as harmless jokes and part of the workplace culture. As the harassment continued and intensified, Mariyam's job performance began to suffer. She found herself constantly stressed, unable to concentrate on her work, and increasingly uncomfortable in team meetings and collaborative projects. The toxic work environment was taking a toll on her mental health and career prospects. Karan, a colleague who joined XYZ Corp around the same time as Mariyam, noticed the change in her demeanor and the inappropriate behavior of their coworkers. He and Mariyam had become friends, often discussing work-related matters and supporting each other in their projects. Karan was deeply concerned about the situation but felt unsure about how to intervene without making things worse for Mariyam. One day, Mariyam received an exceptionally offensive message from a senior team member, leaving her in tears for several hours. Karan found her in the break room, visibly distraught, and spent time consoling her. After hearing the full extent of the harassment she had been enduring, Karan suggested she file a complaint under the POSH (Prevention of Sexual Harassment) Act. He explained that the Act was designed to protect employees like her and that the company was legally obligated to address such complaints. However, Mariyam, fearing retaliation and the potential loss of her job, refused to lodge the complaint. She expressed concerns about being labeled a troublemaker and worried that it might affect her future career prospects in the industry. Mariyam also mentioned that her family was dependent on her income, and she could not risk losing her job. Karan is aware that the POSH Act permits lodging a complaint on behalf of the aggrieved woman. He is considering reporting the incident himself, believing that the toxic work environment needs to be addressed for the sake of Mariyam and other female employees. However, he is wary about the impact this may have on Mariyam, especially given her reluctance to come forward. Adding to the complexity of the situation, Karan recently overheard a conversation suggesting that XYZ Corp is planning a major expansion, which could lead to promotions and new opportunities for employees. He worries that filing a complaint might jeopardize not only Mariyam's current position but also her future prospects within the company. (a) Discuss the ethical dilemma Karan faces in deciding whether to report the incident against Mariyam's wishes. (b) Evaluate the options available to Karan. Which of these options should he choose and why? (c) What responsibilities do organizations like XYZ Corp have in preventing and addressing sexual harassment and creating inclusive workplace environments? (Answer in 250 words)

Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025

Gender divide manifests itself in diverse range of settings, with 35% women reporting sexual harassment at workplace according to (WEF). This goes against the ethos of Article 14, 15: equality and Article 46 on conditions of work.

(a) Ethical dilemmas Karan faces a slew of ethical dilemmas in deciding to report the said incident(s): - Duty towards friend vs duty towards future female employees - Professional furtherance vs parity furtherance - Ethical egoism of staying silent vs team ethics of safeguarding colleague - Company loyalty vs collegiality principle - Future of Mariyam vs current persecution stress she is undergoing - Offending senior vs conscience preservation - Categorical imperative of Kantian ethics in Mariyam's happiness as an end vs hypothetical imperative of Kantian ethics in preserving her as a means to fulfilment of her family's basic necessities

(b) Options available to Karan 1. Staying silent and adhering to Mariyam's request - merits: Mariyam's family saved; her expectations as an agent respected - demerits: apathy on Karan's end; risk to other female employees; conscience bankruptcy 2. Reporting the case immediately without due consultation - merits: POSH, 2013 ensures punitive action against perpetrator; justice to Mariyam; precedential norm of respecting all genders - demerits: Mariyam may lose job; violation of Mariyam's trust; well-known company → livelihood security of employees destabilized; affects own utilitarian ethos

I will choose: 3. Navigating Internal Complaints Committee option with light nudges preempting final remedy to set senior straight

| Action | Justification | |---|---| | Calmly and playfully discussing problematic behaviour with perpetrator | Equanimity before emotional decisionmaking | | Soft nudges of passing mention of judicial punitive action of such comments | Not so much 'carrot but hint of stick' approach | | Ease Mariyam into being bold and replying with steadfast conviction | Agency to the victim, facilitatory courage in her | | On not stopping and apologising, file complaint with ICC himself | Justice as the end. Nothing more important | | Aiding HR in organisation of sensitization of gender behaviour | Gender violence as against corporate ethos of humane dispensation |

Whilst Karan stands charged of causing harm to Mariyam's future, he also knows that she is a 'talented & driven' individual and can flourish best in a safe work culture.

(c) Responsibilities - Humane capital - culturalising and normalising employees' respect: gender, caste etc - respect based on merit are other factors - Employee satisfaction - safe workplace culture - open spaces of reporting incidents - policy of Zero Tolerance eg) HUL, Tata

To effectuate 'Naari suraksha kavach' (Modiji), there is a need to empower her in such micro-settings.