Topper Copies

How are law and justice administered in stateless societies? Discuss with examples.

Aniruddh Yadav

A. JUSTICE

1. Establishment of Guilt

(a) Divination

It refers to the evoking of supernatural for information by manipulative technique eg. Eskimo Shamans bring spirit into object to find truth

(b) Oath

Refers to the promise based on supernatural to tell truth eg. Oraon Tarid is preceded by oath taken sitting on tiger skin

(c) Ordeal

refers to painful acts to determine guilt eg Oraon are to hold burning charwal in hands and if they can tolerate then innocent

(d) conditional Curse

Supernatural fear based method i.e "if you lie, you die", in malice

2. Punishment

(1) Trial

Trial is held & punishment is as per custom or law eg Oraon is tried for clan exogamy & if guilty, excommunicated

(2) Weird Guild

Based on Compensation for other's damages eg. Penal Feast in Melanesia

Primitive Law

Malinowski defines law as the obligation of one person and the rightful claim of another based on social sanction of binding force due to mutual consent.

Function

1. Regulates behaviour in society 2. Sets cultural norms & enforce 3. Maintain adaptability of Society 4. Set regulations for marriage rules etc and punishment and dispute resolution

Characteristics

1. Almost always Criminal law, not civil 2. No difference between torts and Crime 3. Based on coercion, precedent & legitimacy 4. It's culture bound and culture specific