Is the family universal? Critically examine how various anthropologists viewed the Family.
Aniruddh Yadav
Definition
Family according to W.N. Stephens is based on marriage contract and involves rights and duties with respect to parentage, common residence for husband, wife and children and reciprocal economic obligation between husband, wife and Children. GP Murdock defines family as being a social group characterized by common residence, economic cooperation and reproduction. Thus Family can be understood a residential unit within a society based on affinal and consanguineas relations,
Universality
LH morgon in "systems of Consanguinity and Affinity in human families" describes the various bonds between people and hence the basic reproduction bond is the strongest bond and gives Two types of familial relationships
(a) Affinal bonds
[a kinship diagram of affinal bonds with ego marked]
Affinal kin are bonds formed due to conjugal Ties and are not blood relation
(b) Consanguinous bond
[a kinship diagram of consanguineous bonds with ego marked]
consanguineous bonds are blood relation between close kin
Thus L H Morgan stressed on Universality of kin bonds within Family. Ralph Linton stressed on the universal type of family and considered consanguine extended family as the universal type. G P Murdock stressed on Nuclear Family and considered it to be the universal type of family present in all societies due to functions of Sex, reproduction, Education and Economic Cooperation M. Spiro through his studies of kibbutzim stressed on nuclear family as he saw the failure of Kibbutz as an alternative R.C Brown considered study of family redundant and stressed on need to study different kin bonds which are universal such as mother-son bond etc.
Thus it is clear that Family exists in all societies however its form an structure varies as per the cultural evolutionary requirement of the society. Thus from a functional perspective of Malinowski, all families provide the function of Sexual, Reproduction, Enculturation and Economic Cooperation and this is thus functionally universal. From a structuralist perspective the common spine of a family is same but overall structure varies, thus such a debate over universal type of families