Various international humanitarian organizations provide emergency aid in conflict zones around the world. Highlight the ethical challenges faced by such organizations. What are the principles that guide international humanitarian work? (Answer in 150 words)
Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025
'Universal humanitarianism' is the cornerstone of organisations like 'Doctors without Borders' wherein 'volunteerism' and 'service to humanity' star the contrasting realities of war.
Ethical challenges 1. Some one's patriot, another one's terrorist - choosing a perspective is pressured onto volunteers 2. Objective ethics of 'Hippocrates': 'To none, do harm' - eg) helping a shot down terrorist 3. Militant and civilian get hurt alike → Kantian universalism or moral relativism? 4. Ethical egoism of saving self before saving others 5. Imperative of human as end or as means? 6. Psychological egoism: all good is done with selfish motto 7. Picking 'sides' becomes imperative: patriotic doctor serving nemesis' civilian/military - eg) Hermine Gies saving Anne Frank from Nazis 8. Transparency and responsiveness - eg) fair and objective reporting of facts, not own values - eg) Washington Post charter of values
Thus, with a stark service orientation, not marred by utilitarian motives, imparts a Vivekanandian duty ascription to this world.