In the context of states in India evaluate the relationship between regional disparity and sentiments of regionalism. Is regionalism antagonistic to the idea of nationalism?
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
Regionalism is a concept of political geography, a parochial form of sub-nationalism that seeks to politicize territorial predicaments/regional issues to advance them.
Regional disparity is disparity across states of economic developmental parameters.
Sometimes, regional disparity leads to regionalism
1. an underdeveloped state leads to low self esteem, leading to demand from the Union for more resources - regionalism (eg) Telangana, etc 2. a more developed state leads to fear of migrants taking away jobs (social security) - the sons of soil phenomenon, insecurity - regionalism (eg) Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu, etc 3. a state with low connectivity leads to ethnic sub-nationalism - regionalism (eg) North eastern states, etc 4. a state with low development/high unemployment leads to demand for local reservation in employment (eg) 'sons of the soil' states
Regionalism can also lead to regional disparity
1. regionalism leads to exclusion and instability, and low development leaves the state behind - (eg) the Maharashtra "sons of the soil" movement has harmed development of the state, as it has led to migrants going to Gujarat/Tamil Nadu/Karnataka instead. Thus, regionalism almost always leads to loss of the state itself 2. similarly, regionalism in the North East/J&K prevented integration, and the poorest were worst affected due to lack of development
No, regionalism is not antagonistic to nationalism always. In the positive sense, it can complement and become a force multiplier for nationalism. In the negative sense though, it is simply a way of abusing the most vulnerable in society.
Positive
1. competitive federalism (eg) SDG India index for sound development, (eg) ADP for development of the most backward districts 2. to fight for legitimate rights (eg) water supply
Negative
1. ethnic/linguistic exclusion 2. secessionism (16th Amendment)
These negative forms of regionalism must be suppressed immediately.