The decline of Harappan civilization was caused by ecological degradation rather than external invasion. Discuss
Aniruddh Yadav
The decline of Harappan civilization remains a mystery with multiple theories regarding its demise.
Theories of decline
1. Ecological
- Mortimer Wheeler excavated 7 stratigraphic layers from Indus valley sites indicating at least 7 floodings. - Chronologically Earth was heating and thus riverine flooding was common - most Harappan sites were on river banks
2. External Invasion
- No skeletal remains of Indus Valley exhibit injury or warfare except one skeleton of a male in Barawali, Haryana indicating a lack of conflict - Weapons or tools are very scarce in the IVC history - No large burials as found in Mesopotamian civilization indicating war
3. Self Decline Theory
A Third theory states that the IVC declined due to urban degeneration due to hierarchy and led to its own demise Unsubstantiated theory due to lack of evidence
Conclusion
1. Ecological disruption theory seems to be most likely as no evidence of warfare or internal conflict is seen 2. Arbitrary suddenness of disappearance at the same time also indicate a calamity of severe nature 3. Stratigraphy confirms flooding during the time