What are the principal differences between relative and absolute dating? Discuss two methods each of relative dating and absolute dating, describing the advantages and limitations of each.
Aniruddh Yadav
Absolute and Relative dating methods are both used determine the age of archaeological specimens such as bone, fossils, rock etc. and thus can be used used to chronologically define past cultures
Absolute Dating
It refers to the set of methods that provide exact age in years of specimen subject to probabilistic methods.
1. Carbon-14 / Radiocarbon Dating
Premise 1. It is based on the premise that an organism absorbs C-14 from the atmosphere and food and this absorbtion stops after death. 2. Then the C-14 starts to decay into N14 radioactively with half life of 5730 years.
$C^{14}$ → $N^{14}$ + $\beta^+$
3. Measurement of β ray can provide ratio of C14/C12 to give age.
Limitation 1. Ideal for upto 500,000 years only 2. Standard deviation of ±180 years 3. Atmosphere Content of C14 has changed over the past
2. Amino Acid Racemization
Premise Amino acids in body are all found in the L enantiomeric form and after death undergo racemization to D form at a given rate.
Thus the amount of D form can be determined using spectrometer to give age.
Limitation Water, Temperature, pressure change rate of racemization of Amino Acid.
Relative Dating
It refers to the set of processes used to relatively determine the age of specimens in relation to each other some methods are Patination, Stratigraphy, Collagen analysis, Uranium analysis, pollen analysis, seriation etc
(A) Stratigraphy
Study of strata or layers based on the principle of superposition wherein older layers are found deeper
Limitation 1. Inversion and mixing of strata can occur causing problematic dating 2. Natural and material culture specimens of different time often overlap
(B) Fluorine Analysis
Flouride in ground water reacts with Calcium in bone to give fluoroapatite
$Ca^{2+}$ + $F^-$ → Flouroapatite (Bone) (groundwater)
This is at fixed rate so amount of Flouroapatite reveals age.
Limitation. 1. Rate of reaction varies with Temperature, Pressure, 2. Amount of flourine varies across area