Examine the nature-nurture debate on the origin of caste.
Aniruddh Yadav
The Origin of Caste remains a mystery for all theorists and thus leads to the nature-nurture debate on the origin of Caste.
1. Nature Side
It assumes Caste is a natural phenomenon fundamental to social System
(a) Ideological / Divine Origin Theory - Different Caste originated from parts of the body of Brahma 1. mouth: Brahmins (Speech and knowledge) 2. Arms: Kshatriyas (Power and Action) 3. Thighs: Vaishyas (Sustenance and Food) 4. Feet: Shudras (Support other limbs)
(b) Roid Theory - DN Mojumdar, GS Ghurye and Risley believe that the Aryan invasion led to a superior-inferior difference leading to origin of caste
(c) Mora Theory - Hutton believes that Indian Tribal belief in Mora translated into a hierarchical caste system with evolution of other systems.
2. Nurture Side
It assumes caste is a human phenomenon deliberately propagated.
(a) Brahmanical Theory - A. Dubois in " A description of people of India" states that Brahmins have utilised their position of literary positions to ensure their hegemony is perpetuated by giving hereditary status to varna
(b) Occupational Theory - Nesfield has given the theory
(c) Kelkar's Theory - Evolution of features of patriarchy, pollution and purity and desire to dominate on a psychological level led to establishment of Caste.