Topper Copies

Discuss the theories of the origin of caste in India.

Aniruddh Yadav

Theories of Caste Origin have been provided by multiple sources across history and some are:-

1. Traditional / Divine Origin Theory - All Castes were created from Body Parts of Brahma

It was criticized by Seciriras who said that socio-cultural concept cannot have biological origin.

2. Brahmanical Theory

Abbe Dubois in "A description of Indian people" opined that caste was a modification of varna system by Brahmins to perpetuate Their dominance in society due to influence on literature.

Criticized by Hadden who said that caste literature predates Brahmanical superiority

3. Occupational Theory

Nesfield & David Ibbetson opined

It was criticized by Srinivas who said a small factor of occupation cannot determine a rigid socio cultural system

4. Racial Theory: Based on Aryan Invasion

(a) Risley believed that Aryans prohibited Aryan Dasas (locals) to mate with Aryan woman and some hybrids emerged leading to hierarchy

(b) GS Ghurye believed Aryans had an existing 3-fold system and incorporated local as Shudras in the last livy

(c) DN Majumdar believes hybrid of existing population and Aryans led to complex hierarchy.

Haddon criticised it by saying if raised invasion led to caste formation South America would also have castes

5. Religious Theory

Senart believed Aryans rules of patriarchy, hierarchy, untouchability were the basis of Caste while Hocart says it was due to image of kings as Gods who gave special hierarchal status to all

6. Multifactor Hypothesis

Ram Ahuja, G Ghurye and Majumdar said multiple reasons led to caste formation