Topper Copies

Critically examine the relevance of Anthropological concepts, 'Sanskritization', "Westernization', and "Social Mobility", to the social history of modern India

Aniruddh Yadav

MN Srinivas has explained the concept of social mobility in India in his book "Social Change in Modern India" and utilizes the concepts of Sanskritization and Westernization to understand and justify social change.

Sanskritization

Concept was originally in "Religion and Society among Coorgs of South India" and he only used Brahmanical model of imitation ie. vegetarianism, teetotalism, donning of sacred thread etc. Later he revised the concept and added kshatriya and Vaishya models based on his study of Noniya Gords etc.

He gave the following as characteristics of Sanskritization : 1. Only positional change no structural change 2. Economic and political status was directly linked to sanskritization 3. Non Hindu Castes among Muslims and Sikhs also 'Sanskritized" 4. Imitation was on religious and Secular aspects of life

Impact of Sanskritization

1. Mere imitation was not enough for social acceptance and often led to increased exploitation of lower caste 2. Imitation led to increased orthodoxy and a lower position of Women 3. Increased Education among lower Castes

Criticism

1. For SC Dube The concept is very ambiguous and only explains a singular dimension of social mobility 2. For Yogender Singh. the process was only focusing on brahmins and not other castes 3. For H. Gould it ignored the rebellious and coercive attempts at social change and depicted lower castes as submissive

Westernization

In 'Social Change in India' MN Srinivas defines Westernization as the set of changes occuring due to over 150 years of British Rule and seen in technology, Values, Institutions and Ideas

1. Technology - New agriculture plantation and new tools led to 'western agriculture' - Radio, printing press etc had a massive contribution to education - medicine technology was introduced 2. Institutions - Traditional Institutions of Sati, child Marriage etc were removed - New educational institutions were set up - Army civil services etc were open to all 3. Ideas and Values - Humanism Rationality etc were introduced - Western political and economic Thought was seen

Impact of Westernization

For Seminars it allowed equal opportunity for mobility for lower caste due to secular nature of British and Thus was a parallel process of Social change with Sanskritization

Criticism

1. R. Larcen criticised Srinivas for not including impact of Turkish, French, Portugese etc 2. For Y. Singh the concept bbt room as it did not address modernization and Social Change.