Critically discuss the reasons for sudden decline of Indus Valley Civilization
Laghima Tiwari
Indus valley civilisation existed between 3300 - 1500 BCE in North-Western part of Indian subcontinent. Daya Ram Sahni with discovery of Harappa in 1920 initiated its study. The civilisation suddenly declined, especially its urban areas around 1800 - 1500 BCE. Various theories have been put forward:
1. Theory of Aryan invasion - It is supported by Wheeler (1947), Piggot (1950) and Gordon. - Evidence is provided by Rig Vedic records, hoards of Aryan weapon at IVC sites, skeletal mound at Mohenjo-daro - Criticism :- It is held that decline started much earlier than date of Aryan invasion. Thus, the two events are unrelated. 2. Climate change theory - This was given by Marshall and Stein in 1930s. It held that decline was caused by sudden aridity in Indus valley weather that led to decline of agriculture. - Criticism :- No concrete evidence has been found to prove that climate suddenly became arid. 3. Tectonic theory - It is given by Raikes and Dales in 1960s - It proposed that sudden tectonic movements led to flooding of Indus and its tributaries which led to decline. - Criticism :- later studies of stratigraphic layers of river valleys have lacked evidence to support this view. 4. Hydrological theory :- This was given by Lambrick (1968) and VN Mishra. - It held that decline was caused by sudden eastward shift of Ghaggar and its tributaries to join Ganga river system. This caused lack of water supply to Indus and hence decline of agri-economy - Criticism :- It is similar to the climate change theory but more specific. 5. Chemical theory. :- It laid that decline was caused by sudden thunder and lightning which caused melting of stones even - Criticism :- Theory is too far fetched
Decline of IVC led to PWGs culture of North India which wasn't urban in nature.