Discuss the economic, political, social and cultural dimensions of structural disadvantages of tribes resulting from the subordination after their incorporation into larger social system
Laghima Tiwari
Anthropologists like Verrier Elwin and Haimendorf have highlighted that increased cultural contact with outsiders leading to incorporation of tribals into larger social system have caused economic and cultural impoverishment of tribes.
Disadvantages faced by tribes.
1. economic disadvantages. - They have faced land acquisition, forced displacement and loss of traditional livelihood. - case study - (Tushar Kapoor, 2014) - After setting up of Rourkela Plant, tribes of Munda, Oraon and Kisan had to leave their ancestral homes and traditional agricultural based subsistence pattern. They now work as casual labourers in urban areas. 2. Political disadvantage. - The traditional tribal leadership has declined with incoming of modern democratic institutions. - (Eg) :- Tribal leaders of Mahanto, Rai sabhas among Gonds ; Siem among Khasis and so on. - It has also led to emergence of a section of tribal elites. as they have captured power for themselves. - (Eg) :- Among santhals, subgroups of Murmu (Priest), mandi have gained the most. 3. Social disadvantage - 3.1) Degradation in position of women - for instance, the bride price has been replaced by dowry, women's participation in livelihood has decreased. - 3.2) Increased food insecurity and degradation of health status - case study - K Rohisha (2019) - In Kasargod district of Kerala, 89%. of tribal women are anaemic Out of these 62% and 11% have respectively moderate and extreme anaemia. - 3.3) loss of education, increased illiteracy - This leads to poverty indebtedness and bonded labour. - census 2011 shows that 40% of tribals are below poverty line while national average is of 20%. 4. Cultural disadvantage - The disturbance in Nature- Man - spirit complex as said by LP Vidyarthi has led to breaking of traditional Kinship ties. - The forced displacement and lack of community rehabilitation has further added to it. - Case study :- The Dongria Kondhs right to worship their local deity 'Niyam - Raja' was threatened by Vedanta's bauxite mining project.
Hence, as BD Sharma, Former SC/ST commissioner lays down that there is a need to redefine our development model such that incorporation of tribes into larger society is through their own genius.