Discuss the Anthropological perspectives on the origins of caste India
Laghima Tiwari
Caste system is a form of social stratification in which there is a system of hierarchically ranked, closed, endogamous group, membership to which is ascribed by birth
Anthropological perspective on origin of caste
1. Divine origin theory - laid in 'Purush sukta' hymn of Rigveda. It says that caste has originated from Brahma :-
- Criticism - MN Srinivas says Caste in India follows the jati model and not varna model 2. Racial theory - Given by Risley, Guha etc. - It held that caste originated through interaction of Aryans and indigenous Dasus. - criticism :- 1) Lack of fossil evidence - 2) Similar interaction in other parts has not led to caste system 3. Brahminical Theory - It is given by Abbe Dubois. It holds that caste was created by Brahmin class for their selfish interests so that they can remain at top of hierarchy - criticism :- Gould holds that Caste is so deep rooted for a long period that it is not possible for Brahmins to alone sustain it. 4. Gung or sociological theory. - It holds that caste is divided based on certain qualities - 1) sathik guna - Knowledge - Brahmin - 2) Rajguna - branching, malour - kshatriya - - 3) Tamsik guna - material needs fulfilment - vaishya and shudra - Criticism :- 1) It ignores individual variation within caste groups. 5. Occupational Theory - Nesfield holds that those who performed menial jobs were treated as lower caste, thus caste system emerged. - Criticism :- Occupational division is seen as result and not cause of caste system.
However, no one theory adequately explains the origin. One thing is certain though that early caste was not a closed system like it is today.