Evaluate the effectiveness of the Fifth and Sixth Schedules of the Indian Constitution in safeguarding the rights and interests of tribal communities, providing relevant examples and case studies.
Aditya Vikram Agarwal, AIR 9, 2024
Fifth and sixth schedules of Indian constitution provides for the specific areas categorised as Scheduled areas and Tribal Areas Respectively. Article 244 provide for their administration.
Prominent features
Effectiveness in safeguarding the interests of Tribals Abhishek Bazeey Chakravarthy in his study noted the following positive Impacts: - i) Involvement of tribals in the governance of forests - leading to restoration and conservation of forests. (Eg) Successful implementation of REDD+ initiative in Meghalaya's Mawphlang region. ii) Increased livelihood and income. (Eg) T Haque studied the Mendalekha of gadchiroli and found that bamboo productivity improved leading to increased incomes of tribals. iii) Regulation of moneylending operation by governor. (Eg) Andhra Pradesh (Schedule Areas) Money lenders Regulation Act.
However, the rights of tribals have not be realised fully.
Issues as noted by the Sonum Gayatri Malhotra:- (i) Corruption in the autonomous councils - village heads lead to benefit the most. (ii) Non-uniform laws on forest control and management. (Eg) Karbi Anglong Forests Act do not grant community rights over forest management. (iii) (Other issues) - Mungelkar committee reported that no single direction given by center in last 50 years - Autonomous council power clash with PRIs - Advice of TAC. not followed by governor - low representation of women in the councils.
Proper recognition of tribal and scheduled areas along with implementation of safeguards is necessary to realise the objectives of Tribal Panchsheel.