Pseudo-Tribalism and Implications.
Aditya Vikram Agarwal, AIR 9, 2024
Pseudo tribalism refers to the process by which certain sections of society try to label themselves as 'tribals' despite their non-tribal background.
Reasons of claiming tribal status => Post independence affirmative actions providing reservation to scheduled tribes (STs) under Article 15(4) and 16(4) of the constitution in educational institutions and government jobs. => legal protections under SC/ST Prevention of Atrocities Act. => Economic benefits under various schemes such as Stand up India scheme etc.
Examples of communities - Gujjars of Rajasthan also protesting for ST states despite being classified as OBCs.
Implications (i) Dilution of Tribal Identity : As per Dilip Kanti Chakma - Inclusion of non-tribals in STs erodes concept of 'tribals' diluting their distinct identity.
(ii) Violation of Indigenous rights provided under UN declaration on rights of indigenous people (UNDRIP).
(iii) lower representation of STs in the government jobs - poor policy formulation.
way forward Holistic and data driven identification of STs on the lines of Task force by Hrishikesh Panda (former Tribal secretary) can help.
Pseudo-tribalism deteriorates and dilutes government efforts to provide support to tribals and thus needs to be controlled.