Topper Copies

Critically assess the usage of the term 'tribe' in the Indian context in comparison to the concept of 'indigenous' in global discourse, focusing on historical, legal, and social aspects.

Aditya Vikram Agarwal, AIR 9, 2024

The term 'tribe' was introduced into administration by 1901 census and fully defined in the 1931 census. The adjectives such as of 'depressed', 'aboriginal', 'primitive' began to be associated with the tribes.

According to anthropologists such as V. Elwin, U.K. Srivastava, L.P. Vidyarthi, tribe is a colonial construct with the following characteristics - (i) Primitive economy - low level of technology and absence of all purpose money. (ii) Primitive polity without role of modern democratic institutions - (iii) Remote and Isolated (iv) Primitive religion (v) low population density (vi) Harmonious relationship with nature.

According to ILO convention - Tribes are those communities that have distinctive social, economic and cultural characteristics from the national community and regulate themselves based on there own customs.

Indigenous people are those who have descended from the population that inhabited the country during the time of colonisation or creation of present day political boundaries.

In India, Adivasis (pristine and original settlers) are said to be the indigenous people inhabiting the country for long. But the recent studies, such as People of India Project shows that they have indeed migrated from the other places to their current habitat.

Sence, it is difficulty to identify the tribals in this way, another model is followed.

Scheduled Tribes (STs) President of India under Article 366(25) of the constitution declare tribes under Article 342(1) as STs.

The criteria followed is based on that of lokur committee :- (i) Shyness of contact (ii) Socio-cultural backwardness (iii) Primitive traits (iv) Distinct culture (v) Geographical isolation.

These have been provided legal protection for protection of their distinct culture and preventing their exploitation.

legal protections:- - Forest Rights Act, 2006 - Declaration of schedule 5 and 6 areas - Panchayats (Extention to Scheduled Areas) Act 1996. - Tribal Sub-plan - UN Declaration on Rights of Indigenous People (UNDRIP) signed.

Thus historically what were defined as tribes by colonials are today defined as STs. Tribes was social construct whereas STs are administrative and constitutional category.

There is no doubt that tribes are worst effected by the globalisation and industrialisation (40% displaced are tribals - Nalini Negi and Syata Ganguly). Thus, there is a need to adopt holistic approach for their protection.