Discuss the theories of neo-evolutionism as proposed by Leslie White and Julian Steward. How do they build upon and diverge from classical evolutionism?
Aditya Vikram Agarwal, AIR 9, 2024
Neo evolutionism theory emerged in the 20th century to address the shortcomings of classical evolutionism theories of 19th century
Basic assumptions
Culture develops in a parabolic curve — a social institution is first born, it is different from in gradually develops in different form in different direction and finally moves into original direction in a developed form .
Leslie white Theory
According to him, the culture advances as the amount of energy harvested per capita per year Increase or the efficiency of means of controlling it increases. The socio cultural system consists of three parts — technological, sociological and ideological. The technological aspects are the determinant of cultural system as a whole ( technological determinism ). Law of cultural development :— E X T = C E = Energy , T→ Technology , C→ culture development. As the technology progresses, the energy captured increases and culture develops. Stages of development → savagery, barbarism, civilisation and energy revolution. Each stage respresents enhanced level of technology. Julian steward classified him as universal evolutionist as he was concerned with general evolution of culture
Julian Steward Theory
According to him, all cultures around the world do not follow a single line of development. It was the man-habitat interaction that leads to culture change. This was due to the adaptation to the specific environment. In his work, 'Theory of culture change (1955)' he developed the concept of cultural ecology. The acceptance or rejection of trait was dependent on the local ecology, exploitative technology and socio-economic habitat. He considered himself a multilinear evolutionist as he was concerned with specific evolutions of culture.
Neo evolutionist build upon and diverge from classical evolution in following ways
1. Neo evolutionists believed the development of culture on a parabolic path rather [?] unilinear and sequential. 2. They rejected the idea of independent innovation and utilised more objective criteria of local environment, technology, energy captured etc. 3. They accepted the diffusion of cultural traits by migration. 4. They believed in the evolution of society in several stages and included stages such as energy revolution.
The neo-evolutists gave a new approach and helped in developing concepts such as Nature - Man - spirit Complex (M.N Srinivas).