Topper Copies

How will the structural shift from coal-based power plants to renewable energy generation impact human development in coal-bearing states?

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

There is significant dependence of coal producing regions on coal, for their economy. Hence, structural shift from coal to renewable will have significant impact on human development of coal producing states.

Key cons

1. Employment - coal industry employs 36 lakh workers, (ie) ~0.8% of Indian workforce - however, in states such as Jharkhand, contribution of coal to workforce is 11% - even higher in certain districts - loss of employment will adversely impact education, health, etc 2. Finances - Coal India annually pays ₹50000 cr to District Mineral Foundations (PMF) - apart from that ~20000 cr to union govt as taxes - further amount to state govt as taxes - (ie) ~3% of Govt revenue from coal - Govt expenditure on health, education is less than that - thus, major challenges for financing human development schemes 3. CSR spending by Coal India - on hospitals, etc 4. Pensioned workforce

Pros

1. No resource curse - (ie) renewable energy more decentralized - benefits to larger number of people 2. no resource curse - less incentive for mafia, etc - better law and order 3. less pollution - better health outcomes, etc

Thus, structural shift away from coal will lead to short term challenges, long term benefits.

Way forward: utilise DMF money to future-proof coal districts.