Topper Copies

Critically assess the influence of subjectivity in anthropological research.

Aditya Vikram Agarwal, AIR 9, 2024

Subjectivity in research refers to the researchers' opinion, belief and assumption are reflected in the research.

The concept of ethnocentrism relates to the understanding of culture of someone through prism of one's own.

Influence of subjectivity in research can be seen from:-

1. Evolution of culture – classical evolutionists such as E.B. Tylor, L.H. Morgan gave the theory that culture evolves to civilisation and the climax being victorian or British culture reflecting their subjectivity. 2. The thick description of any culture by the interpretation of a culture by an anthropologist may induce subjectivity isnt it (Clifford Geertz) 3. British diffusionist school considered Egypt as the culture center inducing subjectivity in the research.

Influences the research

1. Gives out wrong interpretation by inducing subjectivity. 2. Ethnocentric bias restricts the ability to understand culture objectively. Eg practice of polygamy in [?] tribes of Jaunsar Bewar (uttrakhand). 3. Reduces the scope of developing true concepts to further research.

However, subjectivity may help in :-

1. Including the emotions and capturing expression during the data collection. 2. provides alternate view of the study through the eyes of researcher.

However, there is a need to inculcate the objectivity as far as possible

=> The concepts such as Historical particularism – every culture owes its uniqueness to past process by Franz Boas was developed based on objective understanding of culture.

=> Some cultural practices can only be understood in the cultural context.

(Ex) Practice of cannibalism among Aztec, or ghost marriages in british columbia.