Examine Claude Levi-Strauss's structuralism and its influence on the study of myth and kinship. What are the main criticisms of his approach?
Aditya Vikram Agarwal, AIR 9, 2024
Structuralism is a school of thought propounded by claude levi - strauss.
Underlying concept
According to this theory, the models making up the social structure are constructed in the mind rather through the thought process. Thus social structure is distinct from empirical reality. He sought to establish facts that are true about human mind rather than about the organisation of any particular society.
Methodology
He applied the methods of structural linguistics. He gave the principles of binary opposition to analyse social realities. This can be seen in his work of Kinship studies and myths.
Influence on the study of Kinship systems
According to him Kinship system acquire meaning only when they are integrated into the systems. These are built by the mind on the level of unconscious thought. He attempts to solve the unconscious logic behind Kinship classification and marriage rules by considring the relationship between their constituent unit.
In his book, 'Elementary structure of Kinship (1949)', he used the concept of incest taboo. Incest taboo exists in every society and they ultimately depend on the property of human mind to think in binary opposites.
Incest taboo regulates the marriage by terming incest as bad and marrying outside as good. This improves the chances of survival (alliance Theory).
Influences of study of myths
According to Levi-Strauss, myth making is the closest of unconscious mind among all the activities of human mind. This is because it is not constrained by social utility. The study of myths help to understand the human thought.
In his four volume work, 'Mythologiques', he explored several hundred myths. He analysed their units and termed them into binary oppositions to bring them into harmony.
(Eg) In his study of myth of 'oedipus complex' in which Oedipus killed his father to marry his mother. The basic unit of this myth must be arranged in a way such as that basic units having same idea are grouped together. These units form binary opposition — good - bad, life-death etc.
Criticism
-> The theory was over dependent on the observed. -> The human thought was depicted as uniform across the world. -> The structural analysis was not applied on a particular society.
Despite its criticism, The theory continues to be used in symbolic and cognitive anthropology.