Topper Copies

Analyze the symbolic and interpretive approaches in anthropology, focusing on the contributions of Victor Turner, Clifford Geertz, and David Schneider.

Aditya Vikram Agarwal, AIR 9, 2024

Symbolic anthropology is a school of thought that seeks to understand study how people understand their surroundings through symbols and their interpretations.

Two major approaches

1. Symbolic Approach by Victor Turner: He investigated symbols as the operators in the social process. He examined how symbols as mechanism operate in the maintenance of society. In his work, Selism and continuity in African Society - he explained how social drama exists as a result of the conflict that is inherited in the society. for him, symbols produce transformations which exert determinable influence inclining people and groups to actions.

2. Interpretive Approach by Clifford Geertz : He defined culture as historically transmitted pattern of meanings embodied in symbols. Thus, symbols operate as vehicles of culture. A symbol must not be simply studied of itself rather what it reveals about the culture. He gave the concept of thick description. It is the interpretation of mental thought process of the natives as made by the enthnographer. The anthropologist acts as inter-cultural translator by interpreting the culture of the natives by developing a thick description of it.

David Schneider retained the Levi strauss idea of culture as a set of relationship. He defined culture as a set of symbols and meanings. Unlike Geertz, he detached culture from everyday life. for him, regularity in behaviours is not necessarily culture.

Criticism

-> The concept focuses too much on 'individual symbols rather than explaining the system of symbols. -> Marvin Harris criticised the theory for excess focus on non-material aspects and mental construct.

Despite its criticism, the theory has helped in studying culture and society through symbols making it more holistic